电离星云中广义的$T_e$([OIII])-$T_e$(HeI)偏差:可能的Case B偏差和温度不均匀性证据

Generalized $T_e$([OIII])-$T_e$(HeI) Discrepancies in Ionized Nebulae: Possible Evidence of Case B Deviations and Temperature Inhomogeneities

摘要 Abstract

HeI单重系的复合线(RLs)物理特性被认为相对简单,并且得到了精确原子模型的支持。我们研究了各种类型电离星云中HeI单重系$\lambda \lambda$3614, 3965, 5016, 6678, 7281以及三重系HeI$\lambda$5876的强度,并与理论预测进行比较,以检验“Case B”复合情景和热均匀性假设的有效性。我们的分析包括来自银河系和河外HII区域的85条光谱、来自恒星形成星系的90条光谱以及来自行星状星云的218条光谱,这些数据均来源于DESIRED-E项目。通过评估HeI$\lambda$7281/$\lambda$6678和HeI$\lambda$7281/$\lambda$5876的比值,我们确定了$T_e$(HeI),并与直接测量的$T_e$([OIII]$\lambda$4363/$\lambda$5007)进行了比较。结果发现,对于大多数天体和星云类型,$T_e$(HeI)系统性地低于$T_e$([OIII])。此外,我们还发现行星状星云中的丰度偏差因子(ADF(O$^{2+}$))与$T_e$([OIII])-$T_e$(HeI)的差异之间存在相关性。我们探讨了两种可能的解释:$n^1P \rightarrow 1^1S$跃迁的光子损失以及温度不均匀性。偏离“Case B”可能表明HI而非HeI吸收了电离光子和/或普遍存在的电离光子逃逸,这突显了详细考虑辐射转移效应的必要性。如果温度不均匀性普遍存在,则识别影响所有电离星云的共同物理现象至关重要。我们的结果表明这两种情景都有助于解释观测到的偏差。

The physics of recombination lines (RLs) in the HeI singlet system is expected to be relatively simple, supported by accurate atomic models. We examine the intensities of HeI singlets $\lambda \lambda$3614, 3965, 5016, 6678, 7281 and the triplet HeI $\lambda$5876 in various types of ionized nebulae and compare them with theoretical predictions to test the validity of the ``Case B'' recombination scenario and the assumption of thermal homogeneity. Our analysis includes 85 spectra from Galactic and extragalactic HII regions, 90 from star-forming galaxies, and 218 planetary nebulae, all compiled by the DEep Spectra of Ionized REgions Database Extended (DESIRED-E) project. By evaluating the ratios HeI $\lambda$7281/$\lambda$6678 and HeI $\lambda$7281/$\lambda$5876, we determine $T_e$(HeI) and compare it with direct measurements of $T_e$([OIII] $\lambda$4363/$\lambda$5007). We find that $T_e$(HeI) is systematically lower than $T_e$([OIII]) across most objects and nebula types. Additionally, we identify a correlation between the abundance discrepancy factor (ADF(O$^{2+}$)) and the difference $T_e$([OIII]) - $T_e$(HeI) for planetary nebulae. We explore two potential explanations: photon loss from $n^1P \rightarrow 1^1S$ transitions and temperature inhomogeneities. Deviations from ``Case B'' may indicate photon absorption by HI rather than HeI and/or generalized ionizing photon escape, highlighting the need for detailed consideration of radiative transfer effects. If temperature inhomogeneities are widespread, identifying a common physical phenomenon affecting all ionized nebulae is crucial. Our results suggest that both scenarios can contribute to the observed discrepancies.

电离星云中广义的$T_e$([OIII])-$T_e$(HeI)偏差:可能的Case B偏差和温度不均匀性证据 - arXiv