基于分层贝叶斯分析研究在线国际象棋中的经验效应

Investigating Experiential Effects in Online Chess using a Hierarchical Bayesian Analysis

摘要 Abstract

胜负效应的存在与否是体育和心理学研究中广泛讨论的现象。然而,这类效应的研究常常受到数据可用性的限制。近年来,在线国际象棋的流行程度激增,提供了大量可用于探索这一问题的数据。通过分层贝叶斯回归模型,我们仔细研究了在线国际象棋中此类经验效应的存在情况。利用大量的在线国际象棋数据,我们发现所有玩家一致的经验效应几乎没有证据支持,但个别玩家显示出一些这样的效应证据。鉴于这些数据的时间特性具有挑战性,我们讨论了几种评估模型适用性的方法,并严格检查了模型的有效性。

The presence or absence of winner-loser effects is a widely discussed phenomenon across both sports and psychology research. Investigation of such effects is often hampered by the limited availability of data. Online chess has exploded in popularity in recent years and provides vast amounts of data which can be used to explore this question. With a hierarchical Bayesian regression model, we carefully investigate the presence of such experiential effects in online chess. Using a large quantity of online chess data, we see little evidence for experiential effects that are consistent across all players, with some individual players showing some evidence for such effects. Given the challenging temporal nature of this data, we discuss several methods for assessing the suitability of our model and carefully check its validity.