摘要 Abstract
复杂系统可以被描述为无数不同的尺度,其因果运作往往具有多尺度结构(例如,一台计算机可以从硬件电路的微观尺度、机器代码的介观尺度以及操作系统的宏观尺度进行描述)。尽管科学家们研究并建模了从微观物理学到宏观经济学的完整尺度层次,但关于系统宏观尺度除了简单的压缩之外还能增加什么仍存在争议。为了解决这一长期存在的问题,这里引入了一种新的涌现理论,其中系统的不同尺度被视为更高维度对象的切片。该理论能够区分哪些尺度具有独特的因果贡献,哪些则在因果上不相关。基于因果的公理概念构建,该理论的应用在马尔可夫链的粗粒化中得到了演示。它识别出所有的宏观尺度因果关系案例:即可以降低到微观尺度,但关于因果关系却是有损的情况。此外,该理论提出了一种因果分配方案,计算每个尺度的因果贡献,展示每个尺度的独特贡献。最后,它揭示了一种新的涌现复杂性度量方法:系统因果作用在尺度层次上的分布程度。
Complex systems can be described at myriad different scales, and their causal workings often have multiscale structure (e.g., a computer can be described at the microscale of its hardware circuitry, the mesoscale of its machine code, and the macroscale of its operating system). While scientists study and model systems across the full hierarchy of their scales, from microphysics to macroeconomics, there is debate about what the macroscales of systems can possibly add beyond mere compression. To resolve this longstanding issue, here a new theory of emergence is introduced wherein the different scales of a system are treated like slices of a higher-dimensional object. The theory can distinguish which of these scales possess unique causal contributions, and which are not causally relevant. Constructed from an axiomatic notion of causation, the theory's application is demonstrated in coarse-grains of Markov chains. It identifies all cases of macroscale causation: instances where reduction to a microscale is possible, yet lossy about causation. Furthermore, the theory posits a causal apportioning schema that calculates the causal contribution of each scale, showing what each uniquely adds. Finally, it reveals a novel measure of emergent complexity: how widely distributed a system's causal workings are across its hierarchy of scales.