评估横断面阶梯楔形集群随机试验中的中介效应

Assessing mediation in cross-sectional stepped wedge cluster randomized trials

摘要 Abstract

中介分析在独立数据中已有全面研究,但对于相关数据(特别是日益采用的阶梯楔形集群随机试验,SW-CRTs)的研究相对较少。受务实和实施科学临床试验中理解效应机制挑战的启发,我们为SW-CRTs开发了新的中介分析方法。具体而言,基于线性和广义线性混合模型,我们展示了如何估计典型SW-CRTs中四种数据类型(包括连续和二元中介变量及结果)的自然间接效应和中介比例。此外,为了应对暴露时间治疗效应异质性的新兴挑战,我们推导出当总效应随暴露时间变化时SW-CRTs中的中介表达式。对于所有数据类型和治疗效应结构,考虑了聚类刀切法进行推断。我们进行了广泛的模拟,评估所提出的中介估计量的有限样本性能,并在真实数据示例中展示所提出的方法。开发了一个用户友好的R包mediateSWCRT,以促进估计量的实际应用。

Mediation analysis has been comprehensively studied for independent data but relatively little work has been done for correlated data, especially for the increasingly adopted stepped wedge cluster randomized trials (SW-CRTs). Motivated by challenges in underlying the effect mechanisms in pragmatic and implementation science clinical trials, we develop new methods for mediation analysis in SW-CRTs. Specifically, based on a linear and generalized linear mixed models, we demonstrate how to estimate the natural indirect effect and mediation proportion in typical SW-CRTs with four data types, including both continuous and binary mediators and outcomes. Furthermore, to address the emerging challenges in exposure-time treatment effect heterogeneity, we derive the mediation expressions in SW-CRTs when the total effect varies as a function of the exposure time. The cluster jackknife approach is considered for inference across all data types and treatment effect structures. We conduct extensive simulations to evaluate the finite-sample performances of proposed mediation estimators and demonstrate the proposed approach in a real data example. A user-friendly R package mediateSWCRT has been developed to facilitate the practical implementation of the estimators.