基于雨量站观测验证加纳和赞比亚卫星和再分析降水产品的准确性

Validation of satellite and reanalysis rainfall products against rain gauge observations in Ghana and Zambia

摘要 Abstract

准确的降水数据对于气候服务至关重要,特别是在严重依赖雨水灌溉系统的撒哈拉以南非洲地区。由于雨量站分布稀疏,需要依赖卫星和再分析降水产品(REs)。本研究采用点对像素的验证方法,评估了赞比亚和加纳的八种降水产品:CHIRPS、TAMSAT、CHIRP、ENACTS、ERA5、AgERA5、PERSIANN-CDR 和 PERSIANN-CCS-CDR。分析涵盖了空间一致性、年降水量总结、季节性模式以及 38 个地面站点的降水强度检测。结果表明,没有单一产品在所有情境下表现最优,这凸显了应用特定建议的重要性。所有产品在赞比亚和加纳北部的干燥日检测中表现出较高的命中率(POD,70% < POD < 100%,60% < POD < 85%,分别),表明它们在干旱相关研究中的实用性。然而,所有产品在检测强降雨和暴雨时技能有限(POD 接近于 0%),使其当前形式不适合分析此类事件(如洪水)。集成站点数据的产品(ENACTS、CHIRPS 和 TAMSAT)在许多情况下表现优于其他产品,强调了本地观测校准的重要性。由于不同降水总结中的偏差水平不一,强烈建议进行偏差修正。亟需改进的关键领域是强降雨和暴雨的检测,这是目前 REs 面临的挑战。未来的研究应重点关注这一方面。

Accurate rainfall data are crucial for effective climate services, especially in Sub-Saharan Africa, where agriculture depends heavily on rain-fed systems. The sparse distribution of rain-gauge networks necessitates reliance on satellite and reanalysis rainfall products (REs). This study evaluated eight REs -- CHIRPS, TAMSAT, CHIRP, ENACTS, ERA5, AgERA5, PERSIANN-CDR, and PERSIANN-CCS-CDR -- in Zambia and Ghana using a point-to-pixel validation approach. The analysis covered spatial consistency, annual rainfall summaries, seasonal patterns, and rainfall intensity detection across 38 ground stations. Results showed no single product performed optimally across all contexts, highlighting the need for application-specific recommendations. All products exhibited a high probability of detection (POD) for dry days in Zambia and northern Ghana (70% < POD < 100%, and 60% < POD < 85%, respectively), suggesting their utility for drought-related studies. However, all products showed limited skill in detecting heavy and violent rains (POD close to 0%), making them unsuitable for analyzing such events (e.g., floods) in their current form. Products integrated with station data (ENACTS, CHIRPS, and TAMSAT) outperformed others in many contexts, emphasizing the importance of local observation calibration. Bias correction is strongly recommended due to varying bias levels across rainfall summaries. A critical area for improvement is the detection of heavy and violent rains, with which REs currently struggle. Future research should focus on this aspect.

基于雨量站观测验证加纳和赞比亚卫星和再分析降水产品的准确性 - arXiv