再论对流的解析与数值线性分析

Analytical and Numerical Linear Analyses of Convection Revisited

摘要 Abstract

我们针对大于温度尺度高度的区域重新进行了对流的线性分析,采用了解析和数值两种方法。在排除所有耗散的情况下,对流的典型时间尺度由温度尺度高度上的自由落体时间决定。我们定量给出了Boussinesq近似和Wentzel-Kramers-Brillouin(WKB)近似的适用条件。我们重新评估了关键的临界Rayleigh数——这一指标用于表征对流,并表明当温度尺度高度与区域高度相当或更小时,WKB近似倾向于低估临界Rayleigh数。我们清楚地解释了为什么热传导和粘性都需要用来稳定负熵梯度介质。

We conduct linear analyses of convection in domains larger than the temperature scale height. We employ both analytical and numerical methods in these analyses. In the case excluding all dissipation, the typical time scale of convection is determined by the free fall time over the temperature scale height. We quantitatively show the condition for the Boussinesq and Wentzel-Kramers-Brillouin (WKB) approximations to be applicable. We provide a reassessment of the critical Rayleigh number, a key indicator of convection, and show that WKB approximation tends to underestimate the critical Rayleigh number, particularly when the temperature scale height is comparable to or smaller than the domain height. We show clear explanation why both thermal conduction and viscosity are required for stabilizing negative entropy gradient medium.