石墨烯电导率:Kubo模型与非局域量子场论模型的比较

Electric conductivity in graphene: Kubo model versus a nonlocal quantum field theory model

摘要 Abstract

我们比较了石墨烯电导率的三种模型:非局域Kubo模型、由Falkovsky推导出的局域模型以及最后基于非局域量子场论(QFT)极化表达式的模型。这些模型均源自相同的哈密顿量,因此理论上应提供一致的结果。我们确认局域模型是非局域Kubo模型和非局域QFT模型在$\textbf{q}\to\textbf{0}$极限下的合理结果(在为后者引入损耗后)。然而,我们发现文献中现有的非局域QFT模型存在严重不一致性。特别是在真实的非局域区域($\textbf{q}\neq\textbf{0}$),在低频条件下,可用的QFT模型表现出一种非物理的等离子体行为,即跨带横向电导率呈现出异常表现(即使引入不可避免的损耗)。而Kubo模型则显示出预期的行为,即电导率随频率$\omega$变化几乎恒定,并且在$\hbar\omega<\sqrt{(\hbar v_F q)^{2}+4m^{2}}$范围内存在间隙。我们证明了Kubo模型和QFT模型可以通过相同的极化算符$\Pi_{\mu\nu}(\omega,\textbf{q})$来表达,但它们对电导率$\sigma_{\mu\nu}(\omega,\textbf{q})$的表述不同。特别是,Kubo模型使用了标准的正则化表达式,这是欧姆定律和因果律的直接结果,我们在本文中严格重新推导了这一结论。我们还表明,一旦在QFT模型中采用标准的正则化表达式,并加入损耗,则Kubo模型和QFT模型一致,其所有异常现象自然消失。我们的研究结果表明,为了将QFT模型与现有模型连接起来,有必要适当地定义和正则化电导率。

We compare three models of graphene electric conductivity: a non-local Kubo model, a local model derived by Falkovsky, and finally, a non-local quantum field theory (QFT) polarization-based model. These models are supposed to provide consistent results since they are derived from the same Hamiltonian. While we confirm that the local model is a proper $\textbf{q}\to\textbf{0}$ limit of both the non-local Kubo and the non-local QFT model (once losses are added to this last model), we find hard inconsistencies in the non-local QFT model as derived and currently used in literature. In particular, in the genuine non-local region ($\textbf{q}\neq\textbf{0}$), the available QFT model shows an intrinsic non-physical plasma-like behavior for the interband transversal electric conductivity at low frequencies (even after introducing the unavoidable losses). The Kubo model, instead, shows the expected behavior, i.e., an almost constant electric conductivity as a function of frequency $\omega$ with a gap for frequencies $\hbar\omega<\sqrt{(\hbar v_F q)^{2}+4m^{2}}$. We show that the Kubo and QFT models can be expressed using an identical Polarization operator $\Pi_{\mu\nu}(\omega,\textbf{q})$, but they employ different expressions for the electric conductivity $\sigma_{\mu\nu}(\omega,\textbf{q})$. In particular, the Kubo model uses a standard regularized expression, a direct consequence of Ohm's Law and causality, as we rigorously re-derive. We show that, once the standard regularized expression for $\sigma_{\mu\nu}(\omega,\textbf{q})$ is used in the QFT model, and losses are included, the Kubo and QFT model coincide, and all its anomalies naturally disappear. Our findings show the necessity to appropriately define and regularize the electric conductivity to connect it with the available QFT model.