基于最优选择的约束条件资产组合指数跟踪研究:可选增强分析
Asset pre-selection for a cardinality constrained index tracking portfolio with optional enhancement
摘要 Abstract
指数跟踪型投资是一种被动型投资方式,旨在复制市场指数的收益与风险,而增强型指数跟踪则提供超越指数的回报。我们考虑在给定资产数量限制下构建一个用于追踪指数的投资组合,既包括无增强的情况也涵盖有增强的情况。我们将问题分为两个步骤:(1)资产预筛选;(2)选定资产的权重估计。所采用的八种资产预筛选程序包括:前向选择(FS)或后向剔除(BE),并分别通过普通最小二乘法(OLS)或最小绝对偏差(LAD)回归实现,同时考察带常数项(c)与不带常数项(n)的情形。两步法避免了资产选择与权重计算结合时产生的NP难问题,从而通过计算机密集型启发式方法选择约束条件下的指数跟踪资产组合,文献中已有许多针对少于10个资产的案例解决此问题。我们避免这些限制,证明样本外追踪误差大致与1/根号下资产数量成正比。结果表明,OLS相较于LAD更为有效,BE略优于FS,(n)稍优于(c)。对于指数跟踪,无论是无增强还是有增强的情况,我们在对所选时间段和评估周期进行敏感性分析时均采用BE-OLS(n)方法。以标准普尔500指数为例,我们发现样本外追踪误差、交易量以及收益风险比随资产数量增加而改善;而对于增强收益情况,资产数量在10到20之间最为有效。所使用的自2005年3月1日至2023年12月29日的标准普尔500指数数据可供研究人员使用。
An index tracker is a passive investment reproducing the return and risk of a market index, an enhanced index tracker offers a return greater than the index. We consider the selection of a portfolio of given cardinality to track an index, both without and with enhancement. We divide the problem into two steps - (1) pre-selection of assets; (2) estimation of weights on the assets chosen. The eight pre-selection procedures considered use: forward selection (FS) or backward elimination (BE); implemented using ordinary least squares (OLS) or least absolute deviation (LAD) regression; with a regression constant (c) or without (n). The two-step approach avoids the NP-hard problem arising when asset selection and asset weight computation are combined, leading to the selection of a cardinality constrained index tracking portfolio by computer intensive heuristic procedures with many examples in the literature solving for portfolios of 10 or fewer assets. Avoiding these restrictions, we show that out-of-sample tracking errors are roughly proportional to 1/sqrt(cardinality). We find OLS more effective than LAD; BE marginally more effective than FS; (n) marginally more effective than (c). For index tracking, both without and with enhancement, we use BE-OLS(n) in sensitivity analyses on the periods used for selection and evaluation. For a S&P 500 index tracker, we find that out-of-sample tracking error, transaction volume and return-risk ratios all improve as cardinality increases. By contrast for enhanced returns, cardinalities of the order 10 to 20 are most effective. The S&P 500 data used from 3/1/2005 to 29/12/2023 is available to researchers.