摘要 Abstract
本文分析了结构向量自回归(SVAR)模型中,结构性参数仅在局部而非全域可识别的情形。在这种情况下,存在一组孤立的结构性参数点,在施加的约束下具有相同的观测结果。尽管数据无法告诉我们应选择哪个等效点,但常见的频率学派做法是通过最大似然估计获取一个点,并据此进行脉冲响应分析。对于贝叶斯学者而言,缺乏全域识别会导致后验分布对先验分布的非消失敏感性,且多模态的似然函数给计算带来了挑战,因为后验采样算法可能无法探索所有的模式。本文通过提出新的估计和推断程序克服了这些挑战。我们刻画了一类导致局部而非全域识别的约束条件及其对应的等效参数值数量。我们提出了算法以穷尽计算所有满足简约形式参数的可接受结构性参数,并利用它们从多模态后验分布中采样。此外,我们将这组等效参数点视为“识别集”,并发展了针对脉冲响应集合的贝叶斯和频率学派推断方法。一个经验例子展示了我们的提议。
This paper analyzes Structural Vector Autoregressions (SVARs) where identification of structural parameters holds locally but not globally. In this case there exists a set of isolated structural parameter points that are observationally equivalent under the imposed restrictions. Although the data do not inform us which observationally equivalent point should be selected, the common frequentist practice is to obtain one as a maximum likelihood estimate and perform impulse response analysis accordingly. For Bayesians, the lack of global identification translates to non-vanishing sensitivity of the posterior to the prior, and the multi-modal likelihood gives rise to computational challenges as posterior sampling algorithms can fail to explore all the modes. This paper overcomes these challenges by proposing novel estimation and inference procedures. We characterize a class of identifying restrictions and circumstances that deliver local but non-global identification, and the resulting number of observationally equivalent parameter values. We propose algorithms to exhaustively compute all admissible structural parameters given reduced-form parameters and utilize them to sample from the multi-modal posterior. In addition, viewing the set of observationally equivalent parameter points as the identified set, we develop Bayesian and frequentist procedures for inference on the corresponding set of impulse responses. An empirical example illustrates our proposal.