哥伦比亚街头毒品的EASI模型:异质性和内生药物偏好的研究
EASI Drugs in the Streets of Colombia: Modeling Heterogeneous and Endogenous Drug Preferences
摘要 Abstract
非法毒品消费者对大规模政策变化(如合法化)的反应在很大程度上受到其需求行为的影响。由于个人吸毒行为受到许多不可观测因素的驱动,考虑未观察到的异质性对于建模需求和设计有针对性的公共政策至关重要。本文引入有限高斯混合的精确仿射Stone指数(EASI)需求系统,估计哥伦比亚大麻、可卡因和basuco(可卡因残渣或“冰毒”)的需求,同时考虑角点解和内生价格变化。我们的结果显示,未观察到的异质性在识别可靠的价格弹性方面具有重要意义。该方法揭示了两个常规消费亚群体:“安全型”(娱乐型)和“成瘾型”用户,其中大多数属于前者。“安全型”群体的估计值精确且具有全国代表性,三种毒品均表现出单位价格弹性,可卡因与大麻互补,而basuco则是可卡因的劣质替代品。鉴于哥伦比亚大麻生产成本较低,合法化可能会显著降低其价格。我们的反事实分析表明,价格下降50%将使每位代表性消费者获得相当于363美元的效用支出增加,政府税收收入增加1.2亿美元,毒贩收入损失1.27亿美元。因此,合法化有可能减少与毒品相关的犯罪活动,这是哥伦比亚目前暴力犯罪的最大来源。
The response of illicit drug consumers to large-scale policy changes, such as legalization, is heavily mediated by their demand behavior. Since individual drug use is driven by many unobservable factors, accounting for unobserved heterogeneity is crucial for modeling demand and designing targeted public policies. This paper introduces a finite Gaussian mixture of Exact Affine Stone Index (EASI) demand systems to estimate the joint demand for marijuana, cocaine, and basuco (cocaine residual or "crack") in Colombia, accounting for corner solutions and endogenous price variation. Our results highlight the importance of unobserved heterogeneity in identifying reliable price elasticities. The method reveals two regular consumer subpopulations: "safe" (recreational) and "addict" users, with the majority falling into the first group. For the "safe" group, whose estimates are precise and nationally representative, all three drugs exhibit unitary price elasticities, with cocaine being complementary to marijuana and basuco an inferior substitute to cocaine. Given the low production cost of marijuana in Colombia, legalization is likely to drive prices down significantly. Our counterfactual analysis suggests that a 50% price decrease would result in a \$363 USD gain in utility-equivalent expenditure per representative consumer, \$120 million USD in government tax revenue, and a \$127 million USD revenue loss for drug dealers. Legalization, therefore, has the potential to reduce the incentive for drug-related criminal activity, the current largest source of violent crime in Colombia.